Two conservative judges have expressed skepticism over lifting an injunction that blocks President Obama’s efforts to reform immigration with the “interference” of Congress.
Despite stiff opposition from Republicans, Obama, in a speech to the nation, said, “The actions I’m taking are not only lawful, they’re the kinds of actions taken by every single Republican president and every Democratic president for the past half-century.”
And given the clash between lawyers of a 26-state coalition against the federal government, it shouldn’t be surprising that the judge, Andrew S. Hanen, has put an indefinite hold on Obama’s plan.
This executive action in question will shield 5 million undocumented immigrants from deportation but will also offer them work permits as a result.
A rare two-and-a-half oral argument where the Justice Department’s lawyer came under questioning by the judges offered a taste of what is to come in the weeks ahead as the judges deliberate over this issue.
One judge, appointed by George H. W Bush, Jennifer Elrod, said that this legislation could be extended to every undocumented immigrant to remain in the country legally.
Alternatively, Judge Higginson, appointed by Obama, suggested that the courts should not get involved in the way federal agencies exercise authority as this could stop a wide range of government actions as a result.
As for the third judge, Jerry E. Smith, was a bit conservative with his questioning and which was interrupted by immigration activists who had assembled outside in protest against the proceedings.
Given that the judges have not said when they will rule, this panel’s decision definitely means a lot to Obama since he, in an effort to keep his promise to Hispanics, passed this executive action.